mp

A welcome chance to reassess Meyerbeer’s posthumous opera in a new critical edition [MP]

A fine cast of singers are thrown out to sea by a pointless, dismal production [MP]

There is much to savour in this 59 year-old set [MP]

The singing is especially good from some impressive young singers but the staging… [MP]

Coarse at times, but often exciting, as one would expect a bleeding nun to be [MP]

Despite cuts and a less than perfect ensemble, the sense of being a part of an exciting occasion is boldly realized here [MP]

This fills a gap in the musical repertoire of the French Rococo [MP]

A Baroque opera rarity is one of CVS’s happiest releases of recent years [MP]

The only studio recording of Strauss’s biographical opera is a complete winner on all front [MP]

A good cast and excellent sound are featured on Rattle’s challenge to the Mackerras hegemony [MP]

This version of Massenet’s opera is somewhat marred by the coarse recording, but there are a few thrills to be encountered nonetheless [MP]

Beautiful sonorities throughout but the conductor’s approach is an emotional letdown and hampers the stellar cast [MP]

Stravinsky’s own recording is a flawed yet pleasurable account of this little opera [MP]

Johann Strauss’ Hungarian operetta truly sparkles in a performance that commands the field in spite of its age [MP]

A very fine cast and excellent sound makes this a decent version of Wagner’s difficult first opera [MP]

Weber’s magical score is lovingly presented on this fine set [MP]

A long-lost operatic curiosity. Well-performed but recorded harshly, with no sense of stage atmosphere [MP]

Laurent Pelly’s production has matured with age and Brownlee gives the performance of his career in the title role [MP]

Not a first choice recording but worth spending some time with for a few excellent individual contributions [MP]

Worth getting to know even in a less than successful recording [MP]

Vocal riches in a depressingly hyperactive production that is devoid of amusement [MP]

One might go hunting for a more complete version of this opera, but this one does the trick in most respects [MP]

Christa Ludwig’s amazing Witch is the crowning achievement of this still essential recording [MP]

This old recording still has plenty of rewards to offer [MP]