
Domenico Scarlatti (1685-1757)
Sonatas – Volume 3
Angela Hewitt (piano)
rec. 2026, Kulturstiftung Marienmünster, Germany
Hyperion CDA68395 [73]
This is the third volume in a slowly evolving collection of Domenico Scarlatti discs from Angela Hewitt. Volume 1 (review) appeared in 2015, and volume 2 (review) in 2017, so it’s been a while between releases. It’s good to see a project over which time and care is being taken, and each disc stands on its own rather than being labelled as ‘Volume X’ so we can relax a bit without the feeling we’re missing out or become obliged to collect a complete set.
Hewitt’s booklet notes for this recording do not suggest she has any theme in mind for this programme. She engages with the theory that some of these sonatas were conceived as pairs, but as a mixture of the more famous and less frequently heard sonatas we can dip in, mix and match and just enjoy her playing and this gorgeous recording in any way we fancy. The selection is of course well curated, contrasting certain keyboard techniques, slow and fast pieces, as well as major and minor tonalities in an elegant sequence.
I have always admired Angela Hewitt’s playing of Johann Sebastian Bach, but in all of her recordings her chameleon touch brings each piece to life with an idiomatic clarity and uncomplicatedly direct musicality that connects us to artistic voices of the past, always giving composers their individuality of character and distinctive musical space. Domenico Scarlatti’s rhythmic strength is a key factor in these sonatas, and the playing here is rock solid while also shaping musical sentences and paragraphs with a natural sense of breath. No cadence passes unnoticed, but we’re also not being pulled around unnecessarily. As something of an outlier but also as an illustration, Hewitt has chosen the fugal Sonata in D minor, Kk417 as a Scarlatti rarity amongst these sonatas, and it is intriguing to hear how distinctive it is from Bach, while also sharing sequential features and providing an opportunity to work some more lyrical lines into the programme.
There are oodles of Scarlatti recordings around these days, and I picked out Javier Perianes on the Harmonia Mundi label (review) pretty much at random as a reasonably contemporary recording to Hewitt’s. Perianes is recorded in a more overtly resonant acoustic and is very good indeed, but his playing injects a more idiosyncratic feel and at times a more steely touch to these sonatas, perhaps implying a desire to infuse them with more poetic character and expression than sought by Hewitt. There are hardly any overlaps in their programme, but the beautiful Sonata in F minor, Kk466 is given an almost Beethovenian richness by Perianes, where Hewitt, using it to close her programme rather than taking it as a mid-point highlight, is more restrained. She allows the poignancy in the notes to speak for themselves while creating that “deep sense of loneliness” to which we can all relate, and with no need for operatic excess.
The contrasts within the Sonata in D major, Kk145 sum up Hewitt’s approach nicely in general, with unexpectedly wide leaps separated staccato, contrasting with nicely placed legato passagework, moments of the utmost tenderness, and those inbuilt dramatic pauses reminding us of C.P.E. Bach’s theatricality. Hewitt points out that Scarlatti’s tempo markings, as remarked upon by Ralph Kirkpatrick, have more to do with the character of a piece than its metronomic speed. Players make much use of this freedom of interpretation, but Hewitt avoids excessive speeds and virtuosity over musicality while always delivering on momentum and rhythmic bounce, as well as those moments of wildly strumming guitars and little fragments that seem to isolate into musical question marks, as in the Sonata in C major, Kk460. In short, this recording has pretty much everything you could want from a set of Scarlatti sonatas without beating you around the head with them. We await further volumes with both eager anticipation and avuncular patience.
Dominy Clements
Contents
Sonata in D minor Kk1
Sonata in F major Kk446
Sonata in E major Kk531
Sonata in C major Kk420
Sonata in C minor Kk11
Sonata in C major Kk461
Sonata in G major Kk14
Sonata in A major Kk208
Sonata in A major Kk209
Sonata in A major Kk322
Sonata in D major Kk145
Sonata in D minor Kk417
Sonata in C major Kk460
Sonata in F major Kk518
Sonata in F minor Kk519
Sonata in F minor Kk466
Buying this recording via the link below generates revenue for MWI, which helps the site remain free














