Tippett UnaccompaniedChoralMusic Signum

Michael Tippett (1905–1998)
Unaccompanied Choral Music Hugh Cutting (countertenor)
The Carice Singers/George Parris
rec. 2026, St Jude on the Hill, Hampstead Garden Suburb, London
Texts and translations included
Signum Classics SIGCD1019 [53]

Michael Tippett was an accomplished choral conductor. His track record at Morley College included the first recording of Spem in alium as well as the British premiere of the Monteverdi Vespers. And yet his output as a composer of music for choir alone was small. The 53 minutes of music on this disc is enough to contain his complete compositions for unaccompanied choir, all pieces written in the first 25 years of his career. In his notes accompanying this disc, Tippett’s biographer, Oliver Soden, posits a few reasons as to why this might have been, the two most interesting being that Tippett’s imaginative forces worked on a large scale, and that the composer was averse to setting great verse because it necessarily competes with the music. I don’t think anyone looking at Tippett’s body of work would disagree with the first point, and indeed just under a quarter of this disc is taken up with the Five Spirituals plucked from the sweeping canvas of A Child of Our Time. The second is borne out by what’s on the disc. Disregarding the Spirituals, which are of a different order, only three of the texts set here, by Hopkins (The Windhover), Thomas (The Source) and Yeats (Lullaby), come anywhere near ‘great verse’.

So can a small collection of early, somewhat scattered pieces create a truly interesting musical experience? On the evidence of this new disc, undoubtedly. The Carice Singers and George Parris manage to turn what might have come over as a miscellany into a compelling recital. Part of that is how their programme is structured, and a larger part is how they sing: they bring freshness and insight to all of the pieces here to exhilarating effect. Structure first. The two substantial sets of related pieces, the Five Spirituals and the Four Songs from the British Isles, bracket a group of five individual settings, with the Lullaby as the close. The effect is to induce a welcome reconsideration of those middle pieces, which, heard together and framed by the two collections, sound less like occasional works than a group with a character of its own. And finishing with the forward-looking Lullaby leaves matters interestingly poised. The result is that after listening to these varied and imaginative early creations, one is left with a strong sense that they shouldn’t be dismissed as a footnote.

The Spirituals and the Four Songs are a contrasting pair: both date from the later 1950s and have a humanistic focus. The Spirituals speak to collective suffering; the Four Songs were Tippett’s demonstration, for a Bremen festival, of the distinct identities of the four British nations. Musically, Tippett’s approach to each was very different. The Spirituals are kept close to the arrangements in James Weldon Johnson’s anthology, almost as found material, keys unchanged; the Four Songs are so intricate that they proved too much for the German choir they were written for. In the performances of both sets by the Carice Singers, what comes across is spirit and simplicity. They are so at ease with the technical challenges that, for example, a song as familiar as ‘Early one morning’ from the Four Songs sounds completely fresh and new. ‘Deep River’ from the Spirituals is unhackneyed and heartfelt, real emotion emerging from each phrase.

The five miscellaneous pieces in between are equally compelling. Plebs Angelica, for example, is released from the trappings of Evensong and becomes something more interesting than I’d taken it for, the liturgical roll-call of the angelic orders presented with what sounds like genuine awe. Arguably the weakest poem here, Sitwell’s The Weeping Babe, is brought to life by Tippett’s shrill harmonies, revelled in by the singers so that the apparently safe ground of a nativity carol feels thrillingly unstable. It’s an effect Sitwell may well have wanted, but it needed a composer of Tippett’s genius to realise it.

What stands out most for me among these pieces, though, is the contrasting pair of The Windhover and The Source. I’ve said that the core of the album is ‘miscellaneous’ but these two were published together under the title of ‘Two Madrigals’. They’re not really formally recognisable as such — as Soden points out, Tippett’s coronation setting Dance, Clarion Air is ‘more typically madrigalian’, and so it proves in the delightful performance here — but both show a real gift for the madrigalist’s art of word-painting. On the BBC Singers’ recording, as in most catalogues, they appear in the reverse of the order Tippett intended. Side by side here, order restored, they’re the highlight of the disc, along with Lullaby. In The Windhover, Hopkins describes the falcon’s flight in a rush of compound images, one pushed aside by the next. Tippett gives each image its own short musical figure and moves on. Soden calls the result ‘a busy crowd (even jumble)’ but that’s not exactly what I hear in the Carice Singers’ perfectly judged performance. As I said earlier, Tippett feared great verse would compete with great music. Here it doesn’t, because the music takes on the poem’s method. Tippett even borrowed Hopkins’s term ‘sprung rhythm’, the poet’s way of reproducing the stresses that occur in speech rather than being tied to a metrical constraint. He mirrors this by using irregular accents running against the barline. In performance a setting this complex demands that every figure is placed cleanly and the text stays audible. Parris and his singers are electrifyingly lucid: their diction is immaculate, entries crystal clear and balance impeccable.

The setting of Thomas’s The Source, placed second, allows one to follow Tippett’s logic and aesthetic judgement. So we move from the falcon’s rush in Hopkins to Thomas’s broader line: wind and rain, the river breaking out, ‘the triumph of earth’. Thomas wrote it in 1915 and died in the war two years later. Tippett set it in 1942; the two madrigals were written either side of his tribunal as a conscientious objector. Musically, it’s more straightforward, a beautifully constructed and lyrical part-song, sung here with a gracious warmth that feels completely apposite, the conclusion rhapsodic, so that the listener can absolutely believe in the vision of poet and composer which transcends war.

Placed after the Four Songs is Over the Sea to Skye. It was Tippett’s original Scottish choice, but was displaced by copyright considerations and not rediscovered until 2002. In this recital the listener can hear it close to the song that replaced it, but it also means that the lullaby Gwenllian, the last of the Four Songs and exquisitely rendered here, is separated from the setting of Yeats’s Lullaby, sparing the listener two lullabies back to back: a sensible programming decision, typical of the care that’s been taken with the disc as a whole.

I always feel that Yeats’s ambition for Lullaby slightly outstrips the end result. The ambition is to make a lullaby sung by a lover, and to set the beloved’s sleep beside three mythic sleeps: Paris with Helen, Tristram with Isolde, and Leda after being visited by Zeus in the form of a swan. It’s a magnificent conception but there’s no sense of development in the poem, which is related episodically, and, for Yeats, relatively flatly. It feels like a sketch for a great poem. Tippett, I think, recognised this. He provides a build, reaching its peak with the reference to Leda, who gave birth to Helen and so set in motion the chain of causation that led to the Trojan War. The subject matter isn’t coincidental given that Tippett was working on King Priam at the time, and the music is noticeably moving towards the textures of that opera. The format is inventive: the lines of the poem are taken by a solo countertenor, with five singers from the choir responding, very much, it feels, in the manner of a chorus in a Greek play. Hugh Cutting provides an authorial voice that feels deliberately unmoored. He’s declamatory, but also lyrical, projecting a breadth of vision that surely attracted Tippett to the poem in the first place. His colleagues are completely at home in the composer’s new idiom of thin textures and harsh, fragmentary harmonic writing, and they make it work brilliantly: the strangeness and sense of dislocation that Tippett was striving for are superbly realised.

There are two other notable recordings of this repertoire: the Finzi Singers and Paul Spicer on Chandos, and the BBC Singers and Stephen Cleobury also on Signum. Neither has quite the overall sense of coherence of this new release, and fine though the singing is on both, the Carice Singers have the edge, especially in precision of ensemble. Adrian Peacock was one of the BBC Singers on that 2007 release. Here he brings his skills as producer to bear along with engineer David Hinitt, and they have produced a magnificent-sounding recording from St Jude on the Hill.

Dominic Hartley

Contents
Five Spirituals from A Child of Our Time (1957)
Two Madrigals (1942): The Windhover; The Source
Plebs Angelica (1943–44)
The Weeping Babe (1944)
Dance, Clarion Air (1952)
Four Songs from the British Isles (1956)
Over the Sea to Skye (1956)
Lullaby (1959) – Hugh Cutting (countertenor)

Buying this recording via the link below generates revenue for MWI, which helps the site remain free



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *