Opera

Reviews of full operas as well as collections and recitals of arias

Eccles TheJudgementofParis Chandos

Eccles: The Judgment of Paris (Chandos)

(Déjà Review) A forgotten gem which deserves to be rediscovered [RH]

Boito Nerone Naxos

Boito: Nerone (Naxos)

An intriguing rarity, mostly adequately sung but musically very patchy and dramatically incoherent [RMo]

Suppe Capriccio DieSchoneGalathee

Suppé: Die Schöne Galathée (Capriccio)

(Déjà Review) Pleasantly lyrical and pure-toned [RW]

The Phoenix Opera Company

by Philip Harrison

Maria Callas (soprano): Arias Volume 1 (Pristine Audio)

Once again, Pristine breathes new life into two established and indispensable recital classics [RMo]

Verdi: I Vespri Siciliani (Dynamic)

(Déjà Review) A generally well sung performance in the composer’s home town should be watched by opera producers as well as Verdi lovers [RJF]

salieri cublai aparte

Salieri: Cublai, Gran Kan De’ Tartari (Aparté)

The buffa side of Italian Opera in the heyday of Vienna’s pre-eminence [PH]

cilea gloria naxos

Cilea: Gloria (Naxos)

An unjustly neglected opera by the composer of Adriana Lecouvreur and L’Arlesiana [WK]

Gassmann: Gli Uccellatori (Dynamic)

A pleasant diversion which does not engage one’s deeper emotions [MP]

Verdi: Il trovatore (Pristine Audio)

This fast and furious performance of Il trovatore will please some more than others [PT]

Donizetti IlDiluvioUniversale Naxos

Donizetti: Il diluvio universale (Naxos)

A pleasing, generally very well sung performance of what remains essentially second-rank Donizetti but one with some rewarding passages [RMo]

The Royal Opera Season of 1925

by Philip Harrison

GilbertSullivan Utopia OpusArte.jpg

Gilbert & Sullivan: Utopia, Limited (Opus Arte)

Hurrah for the Joint Stocks Companies Act of 1862! Ulahlica! [PH]

Prokofiev: War and Peace (BSO Recordings)

An interpretation of Prokofiev’s epic for our times [DHa]

Wagner siegfried OA0948D

Wagner: Siegfried (Opus Arte)

This Siegfried definitely had me hooked from beginning to end [GF]

simon boccanegra crqeditions

Verdi: Simon Boccanegra (CRQ Editions)

Tito Gobbi in one of his great roles at Covent Garden, by way of the BBC [PH]

Donizetti: Alfredo il Grande (Naxos)

Alfred battles with the Danes and the lack of star-quality singers in this slightly disappointing release [MP]

TheSealWoman RetrospectOpera

Kennedy-Fraser/Bantock: The Seal Woman (Retrospect Opera)

Neglected Hebridean songs fused into a folk opera [EJW]

Wagner: Tannhäuser (Warner Classics)

A swings-and-roundabouts recording of the Dresden version of Tannhäuser – stick with Konwitschny and Solti [RMo]

verdi macbeth cmajor

Verdi: Macbeth (C Major)

A mediocre staging of Verdi’s first Shakespearean opera [DHa]

grace williams parlour lyrita

G Williams: The Parlour (Lyrita)

A historic recording of Grace Williams’ unique opera [PH]

rossini otello operarara

Rossini: Otello (Opera Rara)

(Déjà Review) A natural aural ambience tells in its favour as does the liveliness and vibrancy of the chorus [RJF]

Prokofiev War BSOREC2006

Prokofiev: War and Peace (BSO Recordings)

Excellent performances, but the Regietheater production, with cuts and changes, might undermine its artistic worth for many [RC]

Wagner TestamentSBT41393

Wagner: Götterdämmerung (Testament)

Keilberth ends Götterdammerung splendidly but that’s not enough – the world does not sound as though it is collapsing [DH]