Schubert Lieder v2 Bostridge Warner 5571412

Déjà Review: this review was first published in October 2001 and the recording is still available.

Franz Schubert (1797-1828)
Lieder Volume 2
Ian Bostridge (tenor)
Julius Drake (piano)
rec. 2000, St George’s, Brandon Hill, Bristol, UK
Originally released on EMI 5571412
Warner Classics 5571412 [67]

Ian Bostridge has risen to become one of the world’s leading artists, particularly in the lieder repertory. Here is a second volume of Schubert from him, and it is an imaginatively drawn, distinctive programme performed to the highest standard.

There are twenty-one songs in all: with the first half of the recital shared between two favourite poets, Mayrhofer and Goethe, while the remainder are from various others among the hundred or so that Schubert used.

Bostridge responds to the texts with the utmost sensitivity and intelligence, using his remarkable tone control to convey the subtleties and feeling of each individual song. His plangent tone particularly suits Schubert’s lieder, concentrating the mind of the listener through his effortlessly refined technique. Some might argue that a few of these songs benefit from the darker voice of a baritone, for example Willkommen und Abschied. But surely the point is that there is more than one way of realising them, and there is room for both. In any case, the tenor’s tone has developed a richer, more expressive range which enables him to respond to Schubert’s darker moods in a really telling way. Take, for example, the atmospheric imagery of Mayrhofer’s Nachtstück, which is delivered with extraordinary intensity of vision.

These things are easily taken for granted, but they are not easily achieved. Of course the interesting reviews of this disc will be from German-speaking critics: does Bostridge overcome the language-barrier? It seems to the English listener that he does, and since the disc comes with full texts and translations, there is ample opportunity to pursue detailed study.

The EMI recording is warmly atmospheric, just right for allowing a natural perspective. A high point of the recital is the performance of Dass sei hier gewesen, one of the composer’s most emotionally involving songs, and here as elsewhere Bostridge has excellent support from his accompanist, Julius Drake. Their collaboration is developing into one of the key features of their respective careers, a true partnership of equals.

While serious Schubert collectors will rightly maintain their loyalty to great artists like Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau, Janet Baker, Elisabeth Schumann and Hans Hotter, Ian Bostridge is surely worthy of a position in this illustrious gallery.

Terry Barfoot

Help us financially by purchasing from

Presto Music

Lied eines Schiffers an die Dioskuren, D.360
Nachtstück, D.672
Auf der Donau, D.553
Abendstern, D.806
Auflösung, D.807
Geheimes, D.719
Versunken, D.715
Schäfers Klagelied, D.121
An die Entfernte, D765
Am Flusse, D. 766
Wilkommen und Anschied, D.767
Die Götter Griechenlands, D.677
An die Leier, D.737
AmSee, D.746
Alinde, D.904
Wehmut, D.772
Über Wildemann, D.884
Auf der Riesenkoppe, D. 611
Sei mir gegrüßt, D.741
Daß sie hier gewesen, D.D.775
Der Geistertanz, D.116